He pretends to be older than sixteen, as he does throughout the novel. Holden says that Lillian Simmons is a phony and that nobody there actually liked her.
Based on your reading of their exchange, is Holden right about Lillian? Not really. She doesn't seem so horrible. The fish symbolize everyone else but Holden is not a fish. He does not care about the fish because he is a duck. The ducks do not stay in the pond all winter; they have to leave, just like Holden had to leave Pencey.
He used to write great stories—so great, in fact, that Holden credits him twice with being his favorite writer. Holden says that he kissed her everywhere but "her face and all. It is implied that Jane may have been a victim of sexual abuse, which is why she completely ignores her step-father. Holden 's relationship with Jane is rather curious. Jane never actually appears in the story, but Holden frequently thinks about her.
Holden , then, regards Jane as a close friend and is probably deeply attracted to her. However, he can never bring himself to even phone her. Holden sincerely enjoys her company, not because she is the most beautiful girl her knows or because he just wants to make out with her, but because he really and truly likes her personality. When Holden thinks about his roommate from Pencey Prep, Stradlater, on a date with Jane , it makes him crazy with jealousy.
Jane Gallagher was a neighbor of Holden's at their summer houses in Maine. They met at the swimming pool at the club after an incident regarding her dog relieving itself on the Caulfield lawn. Holden's mother does not think Jane is pretty. But Holden says that he just liked the way she looked, that's all. Literature Poetry Lit Terms Shakescleare. Download this LitChart! Teachers and parents! Struggling with distance learning? Themes All Themes. Symbols All Symbols. Theme Wheel.
Holden compares Phoebe's behavior to that of the fencing team at Pencey who ostracized him after he left the foils on the subway. Holden considers Mr. Spencer a phony because of his obsequious behavior while Mr. Who is Ernie in The Catcher in the Rye? Category: sports baseball. Ernie is a talented piano player who has his own bar in New York City. Holden has been to this bar with D. What made Holden cry in Chapter 14? Why is Jane so special to Holden?
What do the fish represent in Catcher in the Rye? What is the main theme of the first paragraph? How is Holden a phony in Chapter 9? Is Holden right about Lillian? Why are the disciples so troublesome to Holden? What chapter does Allie die in Catcher in the Rye? What dirty trick did Mr Spencer pull on Holden? What is Stradlater's first name? How did Holden feel when he used to hold hands with Jane? Why does Holden want to run away with Sally? Several critics have noticed the juxtaposition of sex and death in the novel, this scene at Ernie's being one of the more bizarre examples.
Holden concludes that he is "surrounded by jerks. Lillian Simmons, who used to date D. She is annoying in a bubbly, phony way that Holden finds particularly irritating.
The only real thing about her may be her "very big knockers. Holden knows that she only wants to impress him so that he will tell D. Having told her that he was just leaving, he heads back to the hotel. Tattersall having a checkered pattern of dark lines on a light background. Previous Chapter Next Chapter
0コメント